Evictions — a sensible approach

As property managers probably the one question we get asked more than any other is: how do we handle evictions.  Evictions represent the biggest ‘downside’ to being a landlord.  And whether it is a do-it-yourself landlord or an owner who has hired us, the fear of a long, protracted, expensive, legal battle looms large in the back of most landlords’ minds.Image

I learned the hard way.  I am honest and gullible — the perfect stooge for being taken advantage of.  That School of Hard Knocks was pretty hard on me.  But I persevered and survived and came out the other side with a clear and confident methodology to effective management of late pays.  I share it here.

Our rents are due on the first of the month, and late on the sixth.  By the 7th or 8th of the month we contact anyone who hasn’t paid rent.  We will give them up to 2 weeks to pay their rent — with late fees.  We make arrangements for the rent to be made on a specific date.  This is our attempt to be compassionate human beings and treat our tenants with respect.

We also explain to the tenants that we are simultaneously serving them with a 3-day Pay Rent or Vacate Notice.  We further explain that if they pay the rent (and late fees) as agreed then they have nothing to worry about.  But if they fail to make the full payment then we will refer their file to an eviction attorney.  We empower our tenants — they can choose whether they want to continue living in our rental or get evicted.

We do not accept any excuses.  We tell them to be darn sure of the date they can pay the rent because they are now on a short leash — zero tolerance policy is in effect.  By explaining the “rules of engagement” in advance it frees us up to act on them if need be.  When the appointed date comes we follow through.  We either file the 3-day and do not act on it or we refer it to our eviction attorney.

Now, if we serve a 3-day notice and we still do not hear from the tenants then we know we are going to have to take some serious action.  We refer the file immediately to our eviction attorney.

Where most do-it-yourself landlords get in trouble (including myself in the early years) is believing in the promises without backing it up.  Accepting the reason for the late pay without serving the 3-day is simply asking the tenants to walk all over you.  We run across this stuff all the time.  My favorite is the tenants’ who pay their monthly rent every 5-6 weeks.  By the 4th or 5th month they are a full month behind!

Serving the 3-day notice AND giving the tenant some leeway protects the landlord’s interests while respecting the tenants’ needs.  It empowers the tenants’ to determine their future without undermining the landlord’s rights to what has been agreed upon by both parties in the lease.


Peter Nelson is a landlord and President of Full Service Property Management of Seattle, WA.  With over 28 years leasing experience under his belt, he has seen his fair share of late pays.  To his credit, Peter has been successful in staying out of eviction court.those 28 years.  How to get bad tenants out of rentals without going to court — sounds like a good topic for a later blog!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s